Posted on July 26, 2020
(We try to avoid political stuff, but this is the outcome of Black Lives Matter protests and deserves to be here.)
President Trump's deployment of federal agents to Portland and, soon, Chicago and beyond is rightly raising alarms — and legal challenges.
Militarized, anonymized squads with improper training who are sent in without invitation from local authorities and violently sweep away protesters into detention of uncertain legal status are utterly unsuited to an ostensibly free society. Some pushback has already begun. The feds' modus operandi is egregious enough that even the Trump-appointed U.S. attorney for the District of Oregon Billy Williams has requested investigation of their actions in Portland.
But here's something that would make this bad situation worse: the same federal agents raiding protests without independent scrutiny from journalists and legal observers. This is precisely what the administration sought in court filings in Portland on Tuesday. If that argument wins, it will be a serious blow against the rule of law, farcically struck in the name of "law and order."
Subscribe to THE WEEK for only one dollar
The Trump administration's lawyers, of course, do not characterize their demand that way. "Simply put, the federal government has the legal obligation and right to protect federal property and federal officers, and the public has a compelling interest in the protection of that property and personnel," wrote Department of Justice attorney Andrew I. Warden. "The press is free to observe and report on the destruction of that property, but it is not entitled to special, after-hours access to that property in the face of lawful order to disperse." Any injury to journalists, Warden claimed, was accidental, a rare and unintended externality of lawful efforts to prevent further destruction of federal buildings.
Warden's language conjures a picture of pesky journalists poking around vandalized buildings while weary officers try to close shop after a long night. But that's not what's happening. The ACLU of Oregon-led class action lawsuit to which Warden is responding alleges local police and federal agents in Portland have targeted journalists with "flash-bang grenades, rubber bullets, and tear gas merely for seeking to cover the protests" and "assaulted [legal observers] with batons, rubber bullets, and tear gas simply for watching how [officers] were treating demonstrators."
If these allegations have any basis in fact — and the complaint includes video evidence — law enforcement in Portland aren't innocently catching media and neutral observers in the line of duty. They're deliberately warding off public answerability.
Remarkably, the federal filing specifically objected to the conditions of a July 2nd, restraining order enjoining Portland police from dispersing, "arresting, threatening to arrest, or using physical force" against journalists and legal observers who aren't suspected of committing any crime. That barebones standard of press freedom, Warden said, is too much constraint for officers of the federal government, who apparently need to disregard the First Amendment to do their jobs.
This is exactly the sort of routine, procedural assault on media rights I suggested the Trump administration would favor in a column two years ago. It's not the assassinations or open censorship some said we should fear following Trump's rants about "fake news." It's a court filing argued on pragmatic grounds and couched in language of respect for constitutional rights and defense of federal properties. Mundanity and deniability are the strategy's strengths.
This is exactly the sort of routine, procedural assault on media rights I suggested the Trump administration would favor in a column two years ago. It's not the assassinations or open censorship some said we should fear following Trump's rants about "fake news." It's a court filing argued on pragmatic grounds and couched in language of respect for constitutional rights and defense of federal properties. Mundanity and deniability are the strategy's strengths.
Try 6 Risk-Free issues of The Week
SEE ALSO:
More Race Relations Articles
Sexual Bias Articles
Mental Health Articles
How Drugs and Alcohol Affect the Brain and Body
WA. Counselor Directory: find a therapist near you
After months of talks with immigrant advocates, Gov. Jay Inslee is setting up a $40 million relief fund for people who can’t access federal stimulus programs because of their immigration status. Th... read more
In the weeks following the killing of George Floyd, communities across Washington and throughout the country have stood up and powerfully spoken out — protesting, demanding accountability and fighting... read more
Opinion: June 12, 2020 “Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. and Robert F. Kennedy were my heroes growing up in New York in the 1960s. My parents had taught me and my brother to embrace racial justice and tr... read more
Throughout my medical training, there were situations of patient’s refusing treatment based on the color of my skin, even in emergencies. One night, in Charlottesville, Virginia, the buzzing of the... read more